Penalties against Charlton since 1946/1947

shirty5

The list below does not include Penalty Shoot Outs which appear separately.

Sam Bartram. Faced 52 pens. Saved 15. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 9
Syd Hobbins. Faced 1 pen.
Eddie Marsh. Faced 1 pen. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 1
Willie Duff. Faced 25 pens. Saved 5. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 2
Frank Reed. Faced 2 pens.
Peter Wakeham. Faced 6 pens. Saved 1. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 1
Mike Rose. Faced 8 pens. Saved 1. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 1
Ken Jones. Faced 3 pens.
John Hewie. Faced 1 pen.
Charlie Wright. Faced 9 pens. Saved 2.
Tony Burns. Faced 2 pens. Saved 1
John Dunn. Faced 12 pens. Saved 3. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 1
Derek Bellotti. Faced 1 pen.
Mike Franklin. Faced 1 pen.
Derek Forster. Faced 2 pens.
Graham Tutt. Faced 8 pens. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 2
Jeff Wood. Faced 24 pens. Saved 4. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 1
Nicky Johns. Faced 44 pens. Saved 5. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 2
Jim Stannard. Faced 1 pen.
John Vaughan. Faced 3 pens.
Bob Bolder. Faced 36 pens. Saved 8. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 1
Mike Salmon. Faced 17 pens. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 1
Andy Petterson. Faced 7 pens.
Sasa Ilic. Faced 6 pens. Saved 1.
Dean Kiely. Faced 33 pens. Saved 5.
Ben Roberts. Faced 1 pen.
Simon Royce. Faced 1 pen.
Stephan Andersen. Faced 1 pen. Saved 1.
Thomas Myhre. Faced 2 pens. Saved 1.
Scott Carson. Faced 4 pens. Saved 2.
Darren Randolph. Faced 2 pens.
Nicky Weaver. Faced 5 pens. Saved 1.
Rob Elliot. Faced 11 pens. Saved 5.
Carl Ikeme. Faced 2 pens. Saved 1.
Ross Worner. Faced 1 pen.
Ben Hamer. Faced 12 pens. Saved 2
John Sullivan. Faced 2 pens.
Ben Alnwick. Faced 3 pens. Saved 1
Stephen Henderson. Faced 2 pens. Saved 2.


Penalty Shoot Outs

Bob Bolder. Faced 18 pens. Saved 3. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 2
Sasa Ilic. Faced 7 pens. Saved 1
Dean Kiely. Faced 21 pens. Saved 3. Missed pens (Wide/Woodwork/Over) 2
Stephan Andersen. Faced 4 pens. Saved 1
Scott Carson. Faced 5 pens. Saved 2
Nicky Weaver. Faced 5 pens. Saved 1
Darren Randolph. Faced 5 pens.
Rob Elliot. Faced 4 pens. Saved 1
Ben Hamer. Faced 5 pens. Saved 1

ross1

Sasa might have only saved one penalty in a shootout, but what a one to choose!

lordromford

Bloody hell. Sam Bartram was pretty bloody good when facing pens. Only 28 out of 52 scored? That's some going.

happyvalley

Has nobody actually missed a penalty against us since Kiely was in goal?

cafc999

Rob Elliot saved a penalty against west brom

dabos

Ben Hamer definitely saved at least 2 - in the crucial 1-0 win over Leeds which everyone will remember, and in the 4-0 win over Carlisle:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/15319356

cafc999

happyvalley said:

Has nobody actually missed a penalty against us since Kiely was in goal?

Mooney missed a penalty in a cup game a few years ago when he hit the crossbar

E_cafc

Not being picky but didn't Graham Tutt save a pen at The Valley against Plymouth on a Friday night?

shirty5

E-cafc said:

Not being picky but didn't Graham Tutt save a pen at The Valley against Plymouth on a Friday night?

Can't find any record of it in Colin Cameron's book

JohnnyJoeyDeeDee

Ben Roberts faced one against Fulham when Deano was sent off. Saha scored it

Pedro45

Who was the goalie when we played Cambridge away, in the cup, and that game went to pens. We lost...maybe about 1992?

shirty5

Pedro45 said:

Who was the goalie when we played Cambridge away, in the cup, and that game went to pens. We lost...maybe about 1992?

Bolder

Pedro45

shirty5 said:

Pedro45 said:

Who was the goalie when we played Cambridge away, in the cup, and that game went to pens. We lost...maybe about 1992?

Bolder

Ah, OK.

brogib

When did Sasa Ilic save a pen then? ; )

cafc999

Useless info titbit #1

Andy Woodward, who later became our goal keeping coach, was in goal for the Oxford Utd for the cup match that went to a penalty shoot out

shirty5

cafc999 said:

Useless info titbit #1

Andy Woodward, who later became our goal keeping coach, was in goal for the Oxford Utd for the cup match that went to a penalty shoot out

Woodman

cafc999

shirty5 said:

cafc999 said:

Useless info titbit #1

Andy Woodward, who later became our goal keeping coach, was in goal for the Oxford Utd for the cup match that went to a penalty shoot out

Woodman

sorry, I stand corrected

Bermuda_red

shirty5 said:

E-cafc said:

Not being picky but didn't Graham Tutt save a pen at The Valley against Plymouth on a Friday night?

Can't find any record of it in Colin Cameron's book

Think it was Jeff Wood. We won 3-1. November 1976 I think??

paulie8290

Mike Salmon wasn't very good was he

guinnessaddick

It does show the marked increase in penalties against us when we have been in the top flight.

E_cafc

Bermuda_red said:

shirty5 said:

E-cafc said:

Not being picky but didn't Graham Tutt save a pen at The Valley against Plymouth on a Friday night?

Can't find any record of it in Colin Cameron's book

Think it was Jeff Wood. We won 3-1. November 1976 I think??

Think that must be the season after. It was around December 1975 just after we lost 1.5
at home to Luton. Think we beat Plymouth 2.0 and Tutty saved a pen.

E_cafc

paulie8290 said:

Mike Salmon wasn't very good was he

He never got near a penalty as far as I can remember. Usually, you have some
confidence in your keeper when facing pens but with Salmon you just knew
the ball would end up in the net.

guinnessaddick

E-cafc said:

paulie8290 said:

Mike Salmon wasn't very good was he

He never got near a penalty as far as I can remember. Usually, you have some
confidence in your keeper when facing pens but with Salmon you just knew
the ball would end up in the net.

Like a fish out of water.

I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY

Scott Carson saved a penalty vs Bolton in August 2006.

NomSoup

So Henderson currently has a 100% save record

I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY

Nicky Weaver saved a penalty vs Ipswich in 2007

I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY

Rob Elliot saved 4 penalties.

Vs Wolves in 2009
Vs Notts County in 2010
vs Luton in 2010 (FA Cup)
vs Shef Wed in 2011

I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY

Also how can we forget Scott Carson saving Frank Lampards penalty at Stamford Bridge in 2006. (JFH telling him which way to dive).

iaitch

brogib said:

When did Sasa Ilic save a pen then? ; )

Hardly a save, he was lying down on the goal line and Michael Gray passed it to him.

AshBurton

E-cafc said:

Bermuda_red said:

shirty5 said:

E-cafc said:

Not being picky but didn't Graham Tutt save a pen at The Valley against Plymouth on a Friday night?

Can't find any record of it in Colin Cameron's book

Think it was Jeff Wood. We won 3-1. November 1976 I think??

Think that must be the season after. It was around December 1975 just after we lost 1.5
at home to Luton. Think we beat Plymouth 2.0 and Tutty saved a pen.

Yes I remember it too. Bit of a worldy - high flying dive towards top corner, its memory not at all embellished by 40 years having passed in the meantime.

AshBurton

E-cafc said:

paulie8290 said:

Mike Salmon wasn't very good was he

He never got near a penalty as far as I can remember. Usually, you have some
confidence in your keeper when facing pens but with Salmon you just knew
the ball would end up in the net.

Salmon always struck me as a bit of an unusual goalie in that he didn't have much inclination/ability to make diving saves. Just seem to rely on standing in the right place. This tactic proved fairly useless for penalties - and indeed more generally, come to think of it.