Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

HUddersfield vs. Charlton | Player Marks

WSSWSS
edited January 2014 in General Charlton
Well done to everyone who ventured up there and got very well rewarded. Marks if you please!

Alnwick -
Wilson -
Dervite -
Morrison -
Evina -
Jackson -
Stephens -
Ajdarevic -
Harriott -
Church -
Sordell -

Lennon -
Cousins -
Green -

Comments

  • Options

    Alnwick - 8 (Claimed everything, dealt with everything assured some decent one on one saves as well MOM)
    Wilson - 7 (Poor first half, better second half drove forward good link up play)
    Dervite - 7.5 (Solid defended well)
    Morrison - 7.5 (Same as Dervite)
    Evina - 4 (Out of position time and time again didn't press quick enough they targeted him as a weak link)
    Jackson - 7 (Didn't stand out, just stuck to the basics organised the midfield)
    Stephens - 6.5 (Got stuck in thats for sure, gave the ball away a few times)
    Ajdarevic - 7 (Like the look of him stood up and frought kept the ball better then Stephens/Jackson when under pressure)
    Harriott - 5.5 (Tried hard, a day where very little paid off)
    Church - 7 (Extra half point for the finish)
    Sordell - 4.5 (Just awful lost the ball on his first touch, didn't win one header, there was effort just had no clue)

    Lennon - 7 (Played well got tight stood firm)
    Cousins - 6.5 (Broke up play, positive energy tracked back)
    Green - 6.5 (Another positive cameo pressed high)
  • Options
    Wasn't Evina injured after 2 mins and then subbed off with an injury? Seems harsh to mark him down for that. Was he on the pitch long enough to have a mark?
  • Options
    Alnwick - 8.5 (cruical first half save)
    Wilson - 6.5
    Dervite - 7.0
    Morrison - 7.5 (extra for crucial blocks)
    Evina - 4.0
    Jackson - 6.5
    Stephens - 7.0
    Ajdarevic - 8.0 (did he misplace a pass)
    Harriott - 6.0
    Church - 6.5 (0.5 for the goal)
    Sordell - 6.0

    Lennon - 7.0 (very good debut out of position)
    Cousins - 6.5
    Green - 6.0
  • Options
    edited January 2014

    Wasn't Evina injured after 2 mins and then subbed off with an injury? Seems harsh to mark him down for that. Was he on the pitch long enough to have a mark?

    Was subbed just after 30 mins so yes he was on long enough to be marked. He did get a knock earlier though as @addickedandy says.
  • Options
    He was on for 35 mins, Hammill had so much space and time every time he got the ball he managed to whip a dangeous ball into the box which Alnwick, Morrison and Dervite had to deal with. His reaction was so slow Huddersfield had taken a short corner Evina had his back turned chatting to Alnwick Just wasn't switched on. Jackson, Morrison & Dervite all took it in turns to tell him who he was marking when to press, where he should be. In his defence Harriott didn't offer much in terms of support and protection. Personally think Stephens got fed up and dealt with Hammill.
  • Options
    He was actually injured in a 4 minute challenge and tried to play on........
  • Options

    He was actually injured in a 4 minute challenge and tried to play on........

    tried to play on?what for another half hour

  • Options
    Difficult to mark because collectively we were awful first half, but much improved in the scored. Not sure how we got anything out of this to be honest.

    Alnwick - 9. Faultless. Perfect display, kicking good, excellent shot stopping and great commanding of area.
    Wilson - 8. Best outfield player, mostly for his forward runs and excellent work for the assist.
    Dervite - 7. Played well. Comfortable on the ball.
    Morrison - 6. Caught in possession a lot but heroic with the blocks.
    Evina - 5. Was injured from the get go but looked very vulnerable.
    Jackson - 5.5. A passenger for most of the game.
    Stephens - 7. Very good second half. Really wanted it, but lucky not to be sent off with a stupid lunge in the first.
    Ajdarevic - 7. Technically very gifted. Retains the ball well but wish he would close down the opposition.
    Harriott - 5.5. Huddersfield full back had him in his pocket all day, apart from the last 20 mins when he suddenly started to play.
    Church - 6.5. Anonymous first half playing wide right. Much improved second half, especially when moved more central.
    Sordell - 5.5. Ineffective. He isn't a lone striker, especially when the ball is played up in the air and the support and movement around him is non existent.

    Lennon - 6. Comfortable until Scannell came on. Did the basics well but Huddersfield did start to double up on him towards the end.
    Cousins - 6.5 Looked mature when he came on. Surely a better option than Jackson at the moment.
    Green - 6.5 Looks dangerous on the counter attack although at this stage Huddersfield were committing a lot forward.
  • Options
    Just back home after watching a good competitive cup tie.

    Alnwick - Sound as a pound. 9
    Wilson - very competent performance, great assist for Churchie's goal. 8
    Dervite - Very steady. 8
    Morrison - Caught out of position a couple of times but on the whole solid. 7
    Evina - Had a bit of a 'mare. 5
    Jackson - As usual a calming influence. Lasted the full 90 minutes well. 8
    Stephens - Lucky not to have received a red card. 7
    Ajdarevic - Started slowly but got better as game progressed good skills and distribution. 7
    Harriott - A bit of a mixed bag, looked lightweight at times but was better when he cut inside the full back 7
    Church - As usual gave his all for the team, playing a lot of the time quite wide on the right. took his goal well. 8
    Sordell - Oh dear! . 5

    Lennon - Looks a very good prospect. 7
    Cousins - Steadied the midfield when he came on and played just in front of the back four. 7
    Green - Struggled to get in the game but worked hard. 6
  • Options

    Difficult to mark because collectively we were awful first half, but much improved in the scored. Not sure how we got anything out of this to be honest.

    Alnwick - 9. Faultless. Perfect display, kicking good, excellent shot stopping and great commanding of area.
    Wilson - 8. Best outfield player, mostly for his forward runs and excellent work for the assist.
    Dervite - 7. Played well. Comfortable on the ball.
    Morrison - 6. Caught in possession a lot but heroic with the blocks.
    Evina - 5. Was injured from the get go but looked very vulnerable.
    Jackson - 5.5. A passenger for most of the game.
    Stephens - 7. Very good second half. Really wanted it, but lucky not to be sent off with a stupid lunge in the first.
    Ajdarevic - 7. Technically very gifted. Retains the ball well but wish he would close down the opposition.
    Harriott - 5.5. Huddersfield full back had him in his pocket all day, apart from the last 20 mins when he suddenly started to play.
    Church - 6.5. Anonymous first half playing wide right. Much improved second half, especially when moved more central.
    Sordell - 5.5. Ineffective. He isn't a lone striker, especially when the ball is played up in the air and the support and movement around him is non existent.

    Lennon - 6. Comfortable until Scannell came on. Did the basics well but Huddersfield did start to double up on him towards the end.
    Cousins - 6.5 Looked mature when he came on. Surely a better option than Jackson at the moment.
    Green - 6.5 Looks dangerous on the counter attack although at this stage Huddersfield were committing a lot forward.

    Difficult to mark because collectively we were awful first half, but much improved in the scored. Not sure how we got anything out of this to be honest.

    Alnwick - 9. Faultless. Perfect display, kicking good, excellent shot stopping and great commanding of area.
    Wilson - 8. Best outfield player, mostly for his forward runs and excellent work for the assist.
    Dervite - 7. Played well. Comfortable on the ball.
    Morrison - 6. Caught in possession a lot but heroic with the blocks.
    Evina - 5. Was injured from the get go but looked very vulnerable.
    Jackson - 5.5. A passenger for most of the game.
    Stephens - 7. Very good second half. Really wanted it, but lucky not to be sent off with a stupid lunge in the first.
    Ajdarevic - 7. Technically very gifted. Retains the ball well but wish he would close down the opposition.
    Harriott - 5.5. Huddersfield full back had him in his pocket all day, apart from the last 20 mins when he suddenly started to play.
    Church - 6.5. Anonymous first half playing wide right. Much improved second half, especially when moved more central.
    Sordell - 5.5. Ineffective. He isn't a lone striker, especially when the ball is played up in the air and the support and movement around him is non existent.

    Lennon - 6. Comfortable until Scannell came on. Did the basics well but Huddersfield did start to double up on him towards the end.
    Cousins - 6.5 Looked mature when he came on. Surely a better option than Jackson at the moment.
    Green - 6.5 Looks dangerous on the counter attack although at this stage Huddersfield were committing a lot forward.

    Collectively we were awful in the first half yet Alnwick gets a "faultless" 9?

    How does that work then? ;-)

  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Nice to see AA getting a few good marks
  • Options
    Fair point smart a***!

    Perhaps I am being a little too harsh. Huddersfield were very good, especially the first half. They pressed very high and we gave the ball away time and time again mainly because there was never an outlet to pass to. I lost count the number of times they waltzed through us and fizzed the ball across the 6 yard box. If it wasn't for some heroics from our centre halves and keeper and they had a half descent striker, they would have been out of sight. We just weren't in it.

    Strangely as soon as the wind and rain started swirling, we suddenly looked a much better team. Perhaps we are more used to playing in puddles!


  • Options
    edited January 2014
    Alnwick - 8.5 assured, confident, gels well with the back 4, now our no1 keeper
    Wilson - 8.5 made the goal, better coming forward, he gets better every time I see him
    Dervite - 9 ever improving as a defender, good accurate passer, joint m o m
    Morrison - 8.5 solid as a rock, inspirational
    Evina - 5 injured yes but looked uneasy from the outset, we improved markedly after he went off
    Jackson - 9 captain, organiser, can't run anymore but a Bolt fast brain, always available to take a pass, joint m o m
    Stephens - 7.5 lucky not to get a red (thanks Mr Atwell), improved when Cousins came on, tough and committed
    Ajdarevic - 6 most lifers give him higher marks, he deserves a 6 for effort, he didn't hide, was not very effective
    Harriott - 6.5 tries hard and is enthusiastic, his defence has improved, attack ? .. didn't get the service
    Church - 8.5 took the goal well, best I have seen him play, looks stronger, fitter, more aggressive, very good
    Sordell - 6 he's improving but that is not saying much, bit of a spoilt brat approach, showed more effort

    Lennon - 8 looked like his 200th game, assured, calm, quick, no messing about should be a shoo in for Tuesday
    Cousins - 8 he and Stephens make three men, apart they are .75 each, brought finesse and power to midfield
    Green - 7 anonymous but effective , there's an oxymoron for you, did OK+
  • Options
    Alnwick - 7.5
    Wilson - 7
    Dervite - 7
    Morrison - 6
    Evina - 5
    Jackson - 7
    Stephens - 7
    Ajdarevic - 5.5
    Harriott - 5
    Church - 7
    Sordell - 6

    Lennon - 6
    Cousins - 6
    Green - 6

  • Options
    Alnwick -9.5 Excelent, lost half a mark for some wayward distribution
    Wilson -7 Really came into it second half
    Dervite - 9 best defender on our side
    Morrison -6.5 slightly worried about his confidence
    Evina - 3 Poor, out of position, lack of support for Harriot and couldn't tackle
    Jackson - 7 Solid, worked well with AA
    Stephens - 7 Apart from a few misplaced passes best midfielder. Enjoyed the crunching tackle
    Ajdarevic - 6.5 Promising start to his Addick's career. Off the pace for the first 20mins but improved dramatically towards the end of the first half and beginning of second half
    Harriott -3 no link up play, didn't support his full back, poor crosses and didn't beat a player
    Church - 7 Run Churchy run. Harried their defence and some good links with Wilson. And scored!
    Sordell - 6 Couldn't fault effort but no understandind with fellow players

    Lennon - 7
    Cousins - 7
    Green - 7

  • Options
    edited January 2014
    Alnwick - 8 Never put a foot or glove wrong dominated his area when the shells were coming in late on
    Wilson - 7.5 Good performance with attacking menace 2nd half, extra 0.5 for assist
    Dervite - 7 After shaky start solid no nonsense defending comfortable on the ball
    Morrison - 7 Stuck to the task and defended well to keep us in the game
    Evina - 5 Got a whack early on but never looked like he fancied the game at all
    Jackson - 6 Plenty of heart and effort from the skipper as always
    Stephens - 6 Made a crunching tackle could have been sent off, gave ball away in dangerous areas on more than one occasion otherwise ok
    Ajdarevic - 6.5 Solid tallish lad looks cultured but also made a crunching tackle to let their midfield know not to take liberties. Some nice touches composed on the ball
    Harriott - 6 Got through a lot of defensive work with the occasional foray so not able tp play his attacking game
    Church - 7 Extra point for the goal which he took well
    Sordell - 5.5 Doesn't jump for headers, laid the ball off ok but can't remember him having a shot on goal

    Lennon - 6 Didn't look fazed, steady debut but had his hands full when Scannell came on and ran at him
    Cousins - 6.5 Calming influence when he came on
    Green - 6 Tidy did nothing wrong or special
  • Options
    Adjarevic's marks range from 5.5 to 8 so difficult to judge how his debit went.
  • Options
    edited January 2014
    Not MOM material IMO, he was above average and slightly better than JJ, Harriott and Stephens who I docked a point for giving the ball away about 4 times when we were pushing up and quick thinking by the defence, saved his blushes.
  • Options
    Alnwick - 7.5 did all that was asked of him very well, wayward finishing from Hudds made this good afternoon for Ben.
    Wilson - 6.5 chalk and cheese a veritable game of two halves.
    Dervite - 6.5
    Morrison - 6.5
    Evina - 4
    Jackson - 6 not his finest.
    Stephens - 7 what's not to like?
    Ajdarevic - 6.5 as Wilson. Needs to get used to the lack of space and time
    Harriott - 6 see Jacko
    Church - 6.5 see Wilson, tidy finish, looked v pleased.
    Sordell - smart on occasion, messy rather than Messi on others.

    Lennon - 6.5 did all that was asked. Better than John
    Cousins - 7 composure and growing in stature, came on and took control.
    Green - 6 yep
  • Options


    Alnwick - 8
    Wilson - 7.5
    Dervite - 7.5
    Morrison - 6.5
    Evina - 3
    Jackson - 7.5
    Stephens - 7
    Ajdarevic - 7
    Harriott - 5
    Church - 6.5
    Sordell - 5

    Lennon - 7
    Cousins - 7
    Green - 6

  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Some people saying Alnwick was pretty perfect but giving him 7-8. WHAT MORE DO YOU WANT from him?

    Alnwick 9 (10 if he had scored)
    Wilson 7
    Dervite 7
    Moro 7
    Evina 5
    Astrid 7
    Stephens 7
    Jacko 7
    Harriott 5
    Church 7
    Sordell 5

    Lennon 7
    Cousins 7
    Green 6

    We have a problem down the left. Lennon was assured and could start. When is Wiggy back?
  • Options
    Alnwick - 8 Excellent save in the 1st half. Solid and brave under the high ball. Clearly our new No. 1. MOTM.

    Wilson - 7 Steady and reliable. Got forward well in the 2nd half, and an assist.

    Evina - 4 Despite the low score, I will defend Ceddy a little. He got badly clattered very early on, which affected his mobility. I'm not sure that Ceddy's positional play is that good, and he relies on his pace. So, when he's injured...

    Dervite - 7.5 Solid and strong. Good distribution. The best of the defenders.

    Morrison - 6.5 Strong, but less comfortable on the ball than Dervite. Lost possession in a dangerous area in the 2nd half, which gave me heart palpitations.

    Stephens - 6 Lucky not to receive a red. Was over run early on, but got better as the game went on. His improvement was marked once Cousins came on.

    Jackson - 5 Sad to see his legs have gone. As far as I can see, the game passes him by now. Never gives up, and battles so hard.

    Ajderavic - 5.5 Early on, struggled with the pace of the game. He may be the slowest player I have ever seen in a Charlton shirt! But, grew into the pace of the game. Showed some good skill and distribution in the 2nd half. Bit of a curate's egg of a debut.

    Harriott - 5 For a winger, his crossing is woeful. Doesn't seem to want to take on full backs any more. Confidence looks shot.

    Church - 8 Bizarrely, started the game on the right wing. No one can deny Churchy's willingness for the cause, though. Selfless running all game. And an excellent finish for the winner.

    Sordell - 5.5 Had our only 2 chances in the 1st half. Showed good movement all game. His hold up play isn't great, but I'm not sure he should be playing as a lone striker.

    Lennon - 6.5 Should be proud of his debut. Unlike Ceddy, good positional awareness. Did not try anything expansive, hardly stepped outside our own half, but a very good debut.

    Cousins - 6.5 Did make a huge difference when he came on. An energy an aggression that strengthens the team.

    Green - 6 Although didn't do anything dramatic, made us look both more solid, and more dangerous.
  • Options

    Some people saying Alnwick was pretty perfect but giving him 7-8. WHAT MORE DO YOU WANT from him?

    'I did it myyyyyyyyy way' :-)
    Wiggy completes his three match ban on Tuesday I believe.
  • Options
    Alnwick 9 MOM
    Wilson 8
    Morrison 7
    Dervite 8
    Evina 4
    Jackson 7
    Stephens 7
    Ajdarevic 6
    Harriott 6
    Church 7.5
    Sordell 5

    Lennon 7
    Cousins 6
    Green 6
  • Options
    edited January 2014
    Alnwick - 8.5 Very solid. Great save one on one.
    Wilson - 7 Great bit of play for the goal by him and looked positive on the ball
    Dervite - 7 solid
    Morrison - 7.5 A few crucial blocks and interceptions in the first half
    Evina - 3 Seemed to put the whole defence out of shape
    Jackson - 6 Did okay
    Stephens - 7 Extra mark for the tackle that brought life to the game and injured their dangerman
    Ajdarevic - 7 Looked composed on the ball and was positive. Good addition
    Harriott - 5.5 Crossing was poor and made the wrong choices a couple of times
    Church - 7 +1 for the goal
    Sordell - 5 Somehow managed to lose free headers. Not the right playing style for him

    Lennon - 7 We looked a lot more assured when he came on. Solid up until Scannal attacked him
    Cousins - 7 Done well
    Green - 6

    Collectively the first half was woeful. Running around like headless chickens and even the effort wasn't there but fair play to the boys in the second half. On to the next one.
  • Options
    Alnwick - 8 Excellent
    Wilson - 7
    Dervite - 8 motm. Don't rate the bloke at all, but he had a great game
    Morrison - 6.5
    Evina - 2 Sorry, the bloke is stealing a living on these showings like he's never played left back before. Jacko yelling basic positional instructions at him, Hudds targeting him constantly... even Harriot had to help. Lennon came on and did more/looked more assured for his first two mins than Evina's thirty.
    Jackson -7
    Stephens 7
    New bloke - 7.5!!
    Harriot - 5.5
    Church - 7
    Sordell - 5 seems unable/unwilling to challenge properly for headers

    Lennon - 7.5 very impressed, professional and assured
    Cousins - 7 Works so well with Stephens
    Green - 7 Got involved and made some good one touch passes

    These scores may possibly be a tad high, but buzzing from the result!!
  • Options
    closed for marks, stats to follow
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!