Another request from FourFourTwo magazine

Dave Rudd

You may remember that we've helped FourFourTwo magazine in the past. Some months ago we provided a consensus view of our best-ever foreign players, and that article is due for publication in the April issue (out on 1st March).

Now they are asking us to help identify the best 50 players outside the Premier League.

They are asking a straightforward question: who do we consider to be the BEST THREE PLAYERS IN LEAGUE 1? These should not include those who represent Charlton. We'll let the other Clubs deal with that!

There are a few things we need to bear in mind:

• We should base our selection mainly on performances this season, although overall class should be taken into account
• Players who were transferred outside the Football League over Christmas are NOT eligible (such as Marvin Sordell, who has joined Bolton). Loan signings do count, but only if from another Football League club
• We should not base our votes purely on matches we’ve been to, but take into consideration games seen on TV. FourFourTwo wants us to be the voice of Charlton, so opening up the debate with fellow fans is encouraged

OK, over to you, Ladies and Gentlemen. Our deadline is midnight on Saturday 11th Feb. I will then collate the consensus view at that point for onward transmission to FourFourTwo.

Thanks.

legaladdick

Llera is a must (lol)

ValleyGary

Wiggins - Charlton
Rhodes - Huddersfield
Lowe - Sheff Wed

Plaaayer

ValleyGary said:

Wiggins - Charlton
Rhodes - Huddersfield
Lowe - Sheff Wed

Dave Rudd said:

You may remember that we've helped FourFourTwo magazine in the past. Some months ago we provided a consensus view of our best-ever foreign players, and that article is due for publication in the April issue (out on 1st March).

Now they are asking us to help identify the best 50 players outside the Premier League.

They are asking a straightforward question: who do we consider to be the BEST THREE PLAYERS IN LEAGUE 1? These should not include those who represent Charlton. We'll let the other Clubs deal with that!There are a few things we need to bear in mind:

• We should base our selection mainly on performances this season, although overall class should be taken into account
• Players who were transferred outside the Football League over Christmas are NOT eligible (such as Marvin Sordell, who has joined Bolton). Loan signings do count, but only if from another Football League club
• We should not base our votes purely on matches we’ve been to, but take into consideration games seen on TV. FourFourTwo wants us to be the voice of Charlton, so opening up the debate with fellow fans is encouraged

OK, over to you, Ladies and Gentlemen. Our deadline is midnight on Saturday 11th Feb. I will then collate the consensus view at that point for onward transmission to FourFourTwo.

Thanks.

Plaaayer

Stupid boy.

shirty5

Rory Loy - Carlisle
Jordan Rhodes - Huddersfield
Stephen Quinn - Sheffield United

dabos

Jordan Rhodes - Huddersfield
Stephen Quinn - Sheffield United
Dean Lewington - MK Dons

Elthamaddick

think I'd have to agree with Dabos as we can't pick our own players

MattD

Jordan Rhodes
Miguel Llera
Kevin Lisbie

(Really dont know who apart from Rhodes)

peteshep1905

lowton - sheff u
john-lewis - bury
bean - brentford

Richard J

Anthony Wordsworth Colchester
Stephen Gleeson MK Dons
Jordan Rhodes Huddersfield

PeteF

legaladdick said:

Llera is a must (lol)

Without a shadow of a doubt he is a far too good for us....

Weegie Addick

Seems daft that we can't nominate our own players, but have to choose others based on one match actually seen or what we may have caught on TV? Rhodes was utterly useless in the match at The Valley!

I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY

Jordan Rhodes - Huddersfield (obviously)
Ched Evans - Sheffield United
Jose Semedo - Sheffield Wed

Deadred

Andy Keogh, Darius Henderson and Liam Trotter all Millwall.................Oh hang on a minute they're not down yet........Oops!

Bedsaddick

Don't see how anyone can nominate Rhodes. he never got a touch against us.

Ledge

Jordan Rhodes - just cos he hasn't scored against us doesn't mean he's not a good players
Grant holt
Ricky lambert

dabos

Bedsaddick said:

Don't see how anyone can nominate Rhodes. he never got a touch against us.

Because he is comfortably the best player in the division.

Marriott110

llera mcormack david mooney

McLovin

Were the instructions that difficult?

McCombe
Prutton
Rhodes

Callumcafc

Rhodes, Gleeson, Quinn.

MuttleyCAFC

I suppose you need to think which 3 players you would pick for Charlton if you could pick any. Rhodes is a no brainer then it gets harder. Legge always looks decent then I might go with Semedo!

O-Randy-Hunt

Rhodes Quinn Cox

RedArmySE7

Jordan Rhodes
Stephen Quinn
Dean Lewington

Bedsaddick

dabos said:

Bedsaddick said:

Don't see how anyone can nominate Rhodes. he never got a touch against us.

Because he is comfortably the best player in the division.

Well I've only seen him live once ( against us ) and he was comfortably crap.
I can only base my opinion on what I've seen.

rikofold

Tricky one this season. Usually I'd just name players at other clubs who I think would improve ours, but as we're the best team this year it's a little more challenging. So...

Jordan Rhodes - although he struggled against our defence.
Richard Lee - I think he's the best keeper in this division now.
Dean Lewington - although he'd not get in ahead of Wiggins

Crispy

Jordan Rhodes - Huddersfield
Stephen Gleeson - MK Dons
Stephen Quinn - Sheffield United

ValleyGary

Plaaayer said:

Stupid boy.

busy

Oggy Red

Surely the 3 best players in the division are all at Sheff Weds.....?

In fact make that the best 11 players in the division.
I have it on good authority from Owls Talk.

Mortimerwasgod

Lowton - Sheff utd right back
Rhodes - Hudds
Evans - Quality in league one, but pony any level above.

Swisdom

Rhodes and Richard Lee

Furman at Oldham is decent as are Quinn at Sheff u and Semedo

cfgs

Gleeson
Quinn
and
Rhodes

Bill_Stumps

Rhodes - Huddersfield
Evans - Sheff Utd
Quinn - Sheff Utd

Leroy Ambrose

Rhodes - Huddersfield
Quinn - Sheff Utd
Wordsworth - Col Utd

Oggy Red

Wiggins (Bournemouth)
Stephens (Oldham)
Bradley Wright-Phillips (Plymouth)

Nicholas

Rhodes
Evans
Agree about Richard Lee

SE10

Francis (Bournemouth)
Llera (Wedensday)
Mooney (Orient)

Deadred

SE10 said:

Francis (Bournemouth)
Llera (Wedensday)
Mooney (Orient)

What no Lisbie?

SE10

Nah, He's s##t!

Bedsaddick

Is it me but nobody in league one has really impressed me. I'm struggling to think of three players.

Deadred

Bedsaddick said:

Is it me but nobody in league one has really impressed me. I'm struggling to think of three players.

No it's not you Beds it is difficult to notice any of our opposition unless they are real stand out players and as we are the best in the league almost, from front to back, it is even harder to acknowledge. However with benefit of the odd TV game thrown in I would say Rhodes not just on his performance at the Valley, plus the clips of his goals all season, Lee the keeper at Brentford and I quite liked that ginger haired lad in midfield for Oldham - Taylor?

scruffle

Jordan Rhodes - Huddersfield
Stephen Quinn - Sheffield United
Dean Lewington - MK Dons

O-Randy-Hunt

Bedsaddick said:

Is it me but nobody in league one has really impressed me. I'm struggling to think of three players.

1st 2 I picked were Rhodes and Quinn. Couldn't think of the 3rd so just went with cox of orient but I would only have him as a squad player

Addickted4life

Rhodes
Richard Lee
Quinn

THEMCA

Rhodes Hudds
Quinn Sheff U
Semedo Sheff Wed

sam3110

Rhodes
Lee
would have chosen Stephen Dawson, but he moved to Barnsley

Fiiiiiish

Rhodes - Hudds
Osbourne - Brentford
Dawson - Orient/Barnsley

cafcsinger

Rhodes
Quinn
Legge

Stig

Just Rhodes. No-one else comes close to our squad.

loe.ldn.wpack

Jordan Rhodes - Huddersfield
Jose Semedo - Sheffield Wednesday
Madine - Wednesday

ValleyFred

Rhodes
Quinn
Semedo - does his job at DM for Sheff Wed, unlike when we expected him to be more attacking